Barnet Council has refused the plan to turn the old Crown Post Office on High Street into nine flats. Officers found three flats below the minimum size.

Overview

Barnet Council has refused the plan to turn the former Crown Post Office at 63-65 High Street into nine flats. The decision was issued on 9 November and gives seven reasons. Officers found that three of the flats would be smaller than the national minimum, that several would be too dark, and that the building had not been in commercial use for the two years the rules require.

The decision notice was signed by the council’s chief planner. The officer’s report was published on 11 November. Both sit on the council’s register under application 26/3331/PNE.

The application used the Class MA fast track, which lets a commercial building become homes without full planning permission if it passes a short list of tests. It failed several of them.

The seven reasons

The council refused prior approval because:

  • the flats fail the minimum internal floorspace standards
  • the scheme needs outside building work, which Class MA does not allow
  • there was no evidence the whole building had been in commercial use for two continuous years
  • there was not enough information on flood risk
  • there was no legal agreement to stop residents getting parking permits
  • several flats would not get enough natural light
  • there was not enough information on noise from the commercial parts of the site

Three flats below the national minimum

The officer measured each flat against the national space standard. Three fell short:

Flat Type Size proposed Minimum
Unit B One bedroom, two people 42.5 sq m 50 sq m
Unit C One bedroom, two people 43.1 sq m 50 sq m
Unit F Studio 38.4 sq m 39 sq m

The report also says the drawings did not show ceiling heights in the two-storey flat in the roof, Unit H. Without them, officers could not check its floor area against the standard.

A Post Office that moved in February

Class MA only applies to a building that has been in commercial use for at least two continuous years before the application. The Post Office counter was a commercial use. But the officer’s report cites the operator’s own announcement that the branch had moved to a new shop nearby by 17 February 2026.

The application was submitted on 11 September. The report concludes the building had stood empty for nearly seven of the 24 months before that date, which put the scheme outside the fast track altogether.

Too dark, and no flood assessment

The council’s design guidance says the glass in a living room or bedroom should normally be at least a fifth of the floor area. The officer worked out that the ground-floor flats would manage between 7% and 15.8%.

A daylight report by BRE covered the ground-floor flats only. The council said nothing showed the other four flats would get enough light.

The site is in Flood Zone 1, the lowest river flood risk. But the Environment Agency maps it at medium risk of surface water flooding. No flood risk assessment was submitted, and the council’s flood team objected.

What passed

Not every test went against the scheme. The report records that:

  • the council’s heritage officer did not object, because the street front would not change
  • environmental health said any contamination could be handled by conditions
  • highways would have accepted the scheme with a car-free legal agreement, which was never offered
  • the cycle store for 12 bikes was more than the seven long-stay spaces required

The noise objection was about the old garage and side yard at the back. The plans did not say how they would be used, so they could stay commercial next to the new homes.

Who commented

Four people or groups wrote in, according to the report. Two objected and two were neutral, one of them the Barnet Residents’ Association.

The association had no objection in principle and welcomed keeping the shop and the historic front. It said the flats would lack outlook, light and space, and would not be very attractive places to live.

What happens next

A separate application to replace the building’s windows and doors and add a new side window, 26/3670/FUL, was validated on 12 October and is still awaiting a decision.

The applicant can appeal the refusal to the Planning Inspectorate. The register showed no appeal on 19 November. The decision notice also records that the applicant did not use the council’s pre-application advice service.

What it means for you

The old Post Office stays empty for now. Its locally listed front, with the royal coat of arms and the arched post van passage, was never under threat from this scheme, and the council’s heritage officer agreed.

Any fresh Class MA bid would face the same two-year use test, and the report found the building has been empty since February. A future plan for homes here may therefore need full planning permission. That lets the council weigh far more than the short Class MA list, and gives residents a fuller say. Our earlier report sets out what the nine-flat scheme proposed.